What's The Difference Between Romance & Fantasy?

I see the shelves at supermarkets and on Amazon filled with romance.

The titles are titillating, or maybe the word is scintillating.

  • Enemies and Playmates
  • Surviving Passion
  • Lust in the Outback
  • Handcuffed to a Sheik

I see shelves at supermarkets and on Amazon filled with fantasies.

The titles are titillating, or maybe the word is scintillating.

  • Bloodcurse
  • A Magician’s Lover
  • Circle of Sorcerers
  • To Kill a Warlock

In both genres, I am reminded of the man who said he read Playboy Magazine for the same reason he read National Geographic.

“Both,” he said, “are filled with strange, foreign, and exotic locations I will never be able to visit.”

That’s the way I feel about romance and fantasy novels.

Some are really good reads.

Some have really great writing.

Most are packed with a bunch of really intriguing stories.

It’s just that I read those passionate, romantic scenes, and I’m thinking, “That ain’t never gonna happen.”

And I read about the Vampire on the trail of a Warlock who’s the offspring of a monster and a demon, and the demon, I surmise, looked a lot like Rita Hayworth on a good hair day, and I’m thinking, “That ain’t never gonna happen.”

But it does.

It happens every day between the pages of literature: good literature, bad literature, and well-read literature.

I’m not for sure I even know the difference anymore.

Romance is escape fiction. But I can’t picture myself as the tall, muscular, swashbuckling Musketeer riding to the rescue in a shirt that hasn’t been buttoned a single time in the past seventy-five pages.

Fantasy is escape fiction. But I can’t picture myself wandering down the same street with a hip Zombie in ragged, purple hair, trying to free himself from a centuries-old curse and while forever remaining in love with a beautiful Vampire who has come from down deep in the netherworld, which, I figure, lies somewhere between Valdosta, Georgia, and Moab, Alabama.

Frankly I don’t think there’s any difference between Romance and Fantasy at all. Without one, there’s no use looking for the other.

I love fiction. I love all kinds of fiction. But jumping into fiction is a lot like taking a vacation. I usually wind up reading about places I know I won’t ever be able to go.

Caleb Pirtle III is the author of Chasing Love and Other Ghosts.

 

Related Posts