Big publishers are firing the one thing that made them great.
May 17, 2016
Caleb Pirtle III
THESE THINGS were obvious.
Traditional New York publishers had good authors.
But there are a lot of really good indie authors.
Traditional publishers produced good books.’
But there are a lot of indie authors producing really good books.
But traditional had one distinct advantage.
They had great editors.
And great editors, through the years, have often made the difference between good books and great books. For example, when Thomas Wolfe died, his editor, Edward Aswell, began looking through the voluminous manuscript. A few chapters had been completed. Many of the sections were merely handwritten in Wolfe’s typical scrawl, and Aswell had to guess at some of the penciled words.
He discovered that the leading character in the book had at least six different names. Some chapters were written in first person, some in third person. In part of the book, the protagonist had several brothers and sisters. In other sections, he was an only child.
There were stories. There were fragment of stories. There were fragments of sentences. In addition, Aswell was concerned because the manuscript contained at least ten times more pages than the traditional novel. Since there was no one left or around to debate him, Aswell turned the manuscript into two novels: The Web and the Rock and You Can’t Go Home Again. Both would be remembered as part of Thomas Wolfe’s lasting legacy.
That’s what editors did. But editors have become an endangered species.
A couple of years ago, I heard a presentation by Doug Grad, who worked for years as a senior editor for several major New York publishing houses, including Simon & Schuster, Pocket Books, Ballentine, Penguin, and HarperCollins. He worked as the editor on several New York Times Best Sellers.
He’s now a literary agent, and, every day, he watches the publishing landscape change a little. It’s hardly ever for the better.
Once, Doug said, Publishing companies were run by strong-minded individuals who had one passion, and that was to produce outstanding books.
Now it’s all about the money.
Big publishing houses are run by accountants.
To hell with the story.
As Grad said, publishing companies are merging, big publishing companies are buying small companies, and small publishing companies are dying miserable deaths and going out of business.
The man behind the desk no longer cares about books. He cares about money.
He doesn’t read novels. He reads only the bottom line.
Where can he cut costs? That is his only concern.
Who can be replaced? That’s the only question he asks.
He counts heads. He comes up with too many editors.
And New York is becoming more crowded each day with editors out of work and on the streets.
New York publishing houses, in their collective wisdom, are throwing away the one distinction that made them the best in the world. They are discarding their staff of editors, sometimes one at a time, sometimes whole departments by quitting time.
The bottom line may not suffer. The books will.
As Grad points out, “Publishers are telling agents to bring them books that are already perfect. They are certainly not going to spend any money working on them to make sure they’re perfect. So if today’s writers have their books edited, they have to pay for the editing service themselves. Publishers, as whole, are no longer providing it.”
So what’s the difference between traditional publishing and indie publishing?
Historically, big publishers could get books in bookstores.
So many major chain bookstores are going out of business.
Historically, big publishers were responsible for editing.
Now authors pay for editing.
Historically, big publishers handled all of the marketing.
Now the authors have to be in charge of their own marketing.
Big Publishers still pay eight to twelve percent royalties.
Indie authors earn seventy percent royalties after Amazon or Barnes & Noble takes a cut.
So if the advantages are gone, why is anyone running around frantically sending out query letters, interviewing agents at writer’s conferences, and searching for a big publishing deal?
As Doug Grad says, there’s only one way to get a big deal in New York.
Go out and sell 25,000 books on your own, and then publishers will find you.
Don’t go looking for them.
They’re out to lunch.
Personally, I’m perfectly happy with small publishers who care about novels, such as my Secrets of the Dead.